Friday, March 2, 2012

The Forth Amendment Still Exists.............For Now


Last month the Supreme Court of the United States handed down an important opinion concerning the Fourth Amendment and the use of Global Positioning System (GPS) tracking devices to track and monitor suspected criminals, United States v. Jones, 132 S. Ct. 945 (U.S. 2012).  The defendant in this monumental case was Antoine Jones, suspected of drug trafficking by the FBI.  Id. at *2.  For 28 days, the government tracked Jones using a GPS installed under his Jeep.  Id.  The District court convicted Jones and sentenced him to life imprisonment.  Id. at *3. The Supreme Court held that such attachment of a GPS device and the subsequent tracking was a search within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment: “[t]he right of the people to be secure in their persons, house, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated.”  Id.  Thus, the Court affirmed the D.C. Circuit’s reversal of Jones’s conviction “because admission of the evidence obtained by warrantless use of the GPS device, which, it said, violated the Fourth Amendment.”  Id. at *3, 8.  
If you have any questions or concerns regarding what you consider a violation of your Fourth Amendment rights, contact Lindsey Erickson or Dionne Scherff with Erickson Scherff, LLC  at www.ericksonscherff.com for counsel and assessment of your claim or charges. 

Kansas Court of Appeals Remands Prison Contraband Sentence


State v. Warren, 104,489, 2012 WL 516159 (Kan. Ct. App. Feb. 17, 2012)
 Last month, the Kansas Court of Appeals held the district court must consider inmate Warren’s request for a lesser sentence because the district court “wrongly refused to consider the possibility [of a downward departure sentence when] it misinterpreted a sentencing statute.”  Id. at *4.  Inmate Waddell Warren was sentenced to an additional 122 months in prison by the district court after a small amount of marijuana was found in his socks but argued for 40 months based on the small amount of drugs found.  Id. at *1.  The issue addressed by the appellate court was “whether a lesser, or departure, sentence can ever be granted based on the small quantity of drugs involved when sentencing a defendant for bringing contraband into prison.”  Id. at *5. 
The appellate court found that the district court had misinterpreted the Kansas statute, K.S.A. 21-3826, when finding it had no authority to deviate from the sentencing guidelines because “the statute prohibits any contraband in a prison and no specific amount threshold is found in the statute.”  Id.  The court remanded the sentencing concluding, “that the possession of only a small quantity of drugs constitutes a valid factor upon which a departure sentence may be entered on a prison-contraband conviction.”  Id. at *6 (emphasis in original).
Please contact Lindsey Erickson or Dionne Scherff with Erickson Scherff, LLC at www.ericksonscherff.com if you have any questions. 

Monday, January 30, 2012

Do Harsh Pot Laws Create a Dangerous Drinking Culture? 5 Reasons to Get Stoned Instead of Drunk

http://www.alternet.org/story/153870/do_harsh_pot_laws_create_a_dangerous_drinking_culture_5_reasons_to_get_stoned_instead_of_drunk/


How Much Is Spent Defending Sex Offenders?


Effective coverage of the high costs of sex offender civil commitment program in Washington state

The Seattle Times has a very interesting set of pieces today discussing the intricate procedures and high (runaway?) costs involved in the operation of Washington's now-two-decades-old civil commitment program for sex offenders.   This paper and its reporters merit kudos for conducting this in-depth investigation of the longest-running sex offender civil commitment program, and it will be interesting to see how policy-makers respond to a report that seems likely to prompt a political firestorm.
The lead piece, available here, has this headline and subheading: "State wastes millions helping sex predators avoid lockup: Washington's civil-commitment program that shields society from the worst sex offenders is burdened with unchecked legal costs and secrecy, The Seattle Times has found."  Here are excerpts from the start of this lengthy article:
In 1990, Washington became the first state to pass a civil-commitment law, detaining offenders who are deemed by a judge or a jury to be too dangerous to set free. Since then, the controversial program has been plagued by runaway legal costs, a lack of financial oversight and layers of secrecy, The Seattle Times has found.
The state has little or no control over the $12 million a year in legal bills — nearly one-quarter of the [Special Commitment Center's] budget. This results in overbilling and waste of taxpayer money at a time when the agency overseeing the center, the Department of Social and Health Services (DSHS), faces deep budget cuts.
The civil-commitment law has created a cottage industry of forensic psychologists who have been paid millions of dollars for evaluating sex offenders and testifying across the state.
The Times determined that the busiest and best-paid experts include two psychologists who were fired in California, another who has flown here at state taxpayer expense from his New Zealand home, and one who has been paid $1.2 million over two years, some of it for work on cases in which judges questioned his credibility.
Defense teams have hired multiple psychologists — each charging tens of thousands of dollars — for a single case. In at least eight King County cases, the public paid for three or more forensic experts to evaluate the offender or testify for the defense. The state typically hired one expert. Both sides accuse each other of expert shopping.
Defense lawyers repeatedly delay trials, seeking continuances and appeals, which push costs up. In King County, it takes on average 3.5 years for a commitment case to go to trial; several have taken close to a decade. Meanwhile, offenders are held at McNeil Island, by far the most expensive confinement in the state at $173,000 a year per resident.
It takes up to $450,000 in legal costs to civilly commit a sex offender in King County. Defense outspends prosecution almost 2-to-1, says David Hackett, prosecutor in charge of civil commitments.
How some of the money is spent is a mystery. King County judges, at the request of defense attorneys who cited lawyer-client privilege, have indefinitely sealed hundreds of documents authorizing funds for defense experts. The Times fought successfully to get many of these records unsealed, which included psychologists' names and their fees. Hackett said the program needs a financial overhaul. "It's a morass," he said. "We've left the door to the candy store wide open."
Here are links to some of the companion pieces run with this lead article:


Please contact Lindsey Erickson or Dionne Scherff with Erickson Scherff, LLC at www.ericksonscherff.com if you have any questions.